AI-generated image

For more than a decade, China’s e-commerce sector has expanded at breathtaking speed. From the nationwide frenzy of “Double 11” shopping festivals to the ubiquity of instant delivery and livestream sales, online retail became the symbol of modernization—and a barometer of digital economic progress. Policymakers and investors alike came to treat one number, the “e-commerce penetration rate,” as a proxy for China’s digital vitality.

But after years of seemingly unstoppable growth, the curve is flattening. In February 2024, Alibaba Group Chairman Joe Tsai forecast that China’s e-commerce penetration could surpass 40 percent within five years. Instead, the ratio has retreated.

According to the National Bureau of Statistics, e-commerce accounted for 26.8 percent of total retail sales in 2024, down from 27.6 percent a year earlier. From January to August 2025, the rate stagnated around 25 percent.

The reversal has stirred debate. Some warn that the “growth dividend” of internet retail has peaked; others see it as a sign of a broader consumer slowdown. Yet, a structural reading suggests something different: China’s consumer economy is maturing.

The decline in e-commerce’s share is not the end of digital consumption—it marks a deeper shift from a goods-driven society to a service-driven one, from transactional growth toward experiential value.

The Structural Ceiling of E-Commerce

Every economy has a natural upper bound for online retail share, defined by how much of household spending goes to goods, which are easily sold online, versus services, which resist full digitization.

In China, services account for about 45–50 percent of household consumption, and goods roughly 50–55 percent. By contrast, in mature economies such as the United States, United Kingdom and Japan, services make up 65–70 percent or more.

That composition sets the ceiling. Suppose goods consumption in China is 55 percent, and 45–50 percent of those goods are sold online—the total e-commerce penetration would settle around 25 percent. In the U.S., where goods spending is 35 percent, even if 45 percent of those transactions occur online, overall penetration would still be only 15–16 percent.

Japan, long digitized in logistics and payments, has e-commerce at just under 10 percent because its consumption structure is overwhelmingly service-oriented.

Britain offers a similar example. The U.K.’s Office for National Statistics reports online retail at about 27 percent of total sales, a figure inflated by “click-and-collect” purchases—orders placed online but picked up in stores.

In China, by contrast, official data count only end-to-end online orders delivered to the customer. This definitional difference explains why the U.K.’s share appears higher even though much of it still depends on physical fulfillment.

When measured on comparable terms, China’s 25–27 percent plateau is not a warning sign but a structural equilibrium—consistent with an economy that has nearly completed its goods-digitization phase.

From Goods to Experiences

The composition of China’s consumption is evolving rapidly. Growth in online goods sales is slowing, while online services—from travel and leisure to healthcare, education, and entertainment—are gaining momentum. In the first half of 2024, China’s online retail of goods rose 8.8 percent year-on-year, but online services jumped 18.3 percent.

E-commerce excels when products are standardized, comparable, and deliverable at scale. The mass adoption of mobile payments, express logistics, and nationwide platforms enabled China’s retail digitization to surge far beyond that of most economies. But as consumer demand shifts to education, healthcare, wellness, sports, and personalized experiences, growth in purely transactional e-commerce naturally slows.

In these areas, the consumer relationship is no longer defined by price or convenience but by trust, interaction, and emotion. These “experiential” services—whether a fitness class, a restaurant meal, or a medical consultation—cannot be fully replicated in a virtual environment. As China moves deeper into a service-based economy, e-commerce’s relative share of total consumption will plateau even as the value and sophistication of the digital ecosystem expand.

The pattern is consistent across developed markets. The U.K.’s online retail share has hovered around 26–29 percent since the pandemic, mirroring its 79 percent service-sector output. In the U.S., the Department of Commerce places online sales at 16.3 percent of retail as of the second quarter of 2025, roughly matching a consumption structure where two-thirds of spending goes to services.

Japan is even more telling. The Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (METI) reported that B2C e-commerce penetration in goods reached 9.8 percent in 2024—up just 0.4 points from the previous year—despite world-class infrastructure and near-universal internet access. The constraint, again, is structural: with 65 percent of spending on services, Japan’s online retail naturally occupies a smaller share.

Seen through this comparative lens, China’s trajectory is not an anomaly but a natural evolution. As the service sector expands, the proportion of retail that can meaningfully migrate online diminishes. The ceiling reflects not a failing industry but a changing society.

Beyond Penetration: The New Competitive Frontier

For years, China’s retail modernization was measured by how much business moved online. But a mature economy cannot be defined by the height of its digital share alone. A rising service ratio and a stable e-commerce percentage mean the economy is advancing beyond pure goods digitization.

Future competition will not be about capturing “more online share” but about creating richer consumer experiences and building hybrid ecosystems that blend digital convenience with physical engagement. The core metrics will shift—from transaction volume to satisfaction, from price efficiency to brand trust, from delivery speed to emotional connection.

Shopping malls and physical retailers will not vanish; they will reinvent themselves as experience platforms—offering social, cultural, and lifestyle content that complements online interaction. The line between “online” and “offline” will continue to blur, not as rivals but as integrated channels in a unified service ecosystem.

This transformation redefines the meaning of progress. High e-commerce penetration once symbolized modernization; now, the true benchmark will be how effectively a society delivers quality, personalization, and emotional value within its consumption experience.

Industrial civilization thrived on standardization—mass-produced goods, scale efficiencies, and uniform distribution. Post-industrial societies thrive on differentiation—services, creativity, and human connection. China’s e-commerce plateau marks its transition from the former to the latter.

When consumption shifts from “owning” to “feeling,” and from “buying more” to “l(fā)iving better,” retail metrics must evolve too. A flat penetration rate no longer means stagnation; it signals that the digital transformation has reached the level of integration rather than expansion.

As China’s retail sector enters this new phase, the challenge is not to push e-commerce percentages higher, but to redefine what digital means in an experience-driven economy. The next stage of growth lies not in more transactions, but in deeper relationships—where technology amplifies service, and consumption becomes culture.